‘No place to hide'? The facts of command in UK supermarkets SKOPE Research Paper No . 91 May 2010
Irena Grugulis, **Ödül Bozkurt and ***Jeremy Clegg
Bradford University University of Management, **Lancaster College or university Management College, ***Leeds University Business School
Editor's Foreword SKOPE Publications This series publishes the work from the members and associates of SKOPE. A formal editorial process ensures that standards of quality and objectivity are maintained.
Orders to get publications must be addressed for the SKOPE Admin, School of Social Savoir, Cardiff University, Glamorgan Building, King Edward cullen VII Opportunity, Cardiff CF10 3WT Analysis papers can be downloaded from the internet site: www.skope.ox.ac.uk
Fuzy This article is exploring the facts of managerial work in two major United kingdom supermarket stores. While the prescriptive literature embraces the displacement of bureaucratic management by rote with leadership, scientific accounts of what managers actually do underscore how the purported tenets of leadership tend to disappear after closer inspection, even with the discursive level. This analyze observes and discusses the discrepancy involving the rhetoric of leadership articulated by executives at the corporate head offices and the real roles and responsibilities of managers in stores. Function was securely controlled and managers got little true freedom. We draw about empirical data to argue both that while command in practice properly secured only trivial freedoms such freedoms were highly highly valued and that educational analysis ought to follow these types of managers within their ability to distinguish between rhetorical flourishes and reallife job design and style. Leadership in practice is routine and local.
Keywords: leadership, frontrunners, managers, control, deskilling, grocery stores, retail
Intro This article explores the facts of bureaucratic work in two major Uk supermarkets restaurants. While the prescriptive literature welcomes the shift of bureaucratic management by simply rote with leadership (see for example Zaleznik 1992), empirical accounts of what managers and frontrunners actually do underscore how the proposed tenets of ‘leadership' tend to disappear after closer inspection, even in the discursive level (Meindl ain al. 1985, Alvesson and Sveningsson 2003a, 2003b, Tengblad 2004). Kelly (2008) features taken issue with the tendency in the leadership literature of discounting the ordinary everyday work process of managers in lieu of a extended effort to theoretically pin down how management really needs to be conceptualised. This individual argues which the common terminology used by different writers conceals a wide range of practice and that leadership is locally produced. All of us join Kelly's contention that ‘the evidently mundane techniques that are made liable and therefore visible remain unexplicated and positively ignored' (2008: 774) which this is disappointing. We curve from his emphasis on the reification of leadership through language video games, however , and focus rather on the dissonance between the salience of management in the popular and doctor representations of management careers and the actual limits towards the discretion, initiative and control that managers are able to physical exercise in the tangible, routine and core practices associated with all their roles. This kind of dissonance was actively used by the supermarkets' business models. Celebratory accounts of management were cascaded down the managerial hierarchy, from your corporate head office to the department managers, to spur bureaucratic staff to greater efforts in routine work. The empirical material we value to support these kinds of claims originates from a study of managers and managerial operate the stores of two of Britain's largest supermarkets. In the four store sites where exploration was carried out, the work of managers was heavily recommended, with buying, product amounts, stock amounts, store designs, pricing, special offers and staffing policies...
Recommendations: Alimo-Metcalfe, N. and M. Alban-Metcalfe (2005) ‘Leadership: time for a new path? ' Command, 1, 51 - 71. Alvesson, M. and H. Sveningsson (2003a) ‘The superb disappearance act: difficulties in doing leadership. ' Leadership Quarterly, 14, 359 - 81. Alvesson, Meters. and S. Sveningsson (2003b) ‘Managers undertaking leadership: the excess ordinarization from the mundane. ' Human Associations, 56, 1435 - 59. Arrowsmith, L. and E. Sisson (1999) ‘Pay and working time: towards organisationbased systems? ' British Record of Industrial Relations, 37, fifty-one - 75. Baron, S i9000., K. Harris, D. Leaver and N. Oldfield (2001) ‘Beyond convenience: the future for independent meals and grocery retailers in the UK. ' The International Review of Retail, Circulation and Buyer Research, eleven, 395 - 414. Booth, S. and K. Hamer (2006) ‘Labour turnover in the retail industry: predicting the role of individual, organisational and environmental factors. ' International Journal of Selling and Circulation Management, 35, 289 -- 307. Broadbridge, A. (2002) ‘Rationalising price tag employment: a view from the outside searching in. ' International Journal of Price tag and Distribution Management, 30, 536 - 43.
Burt, S i9000. and L. Sparks (2003) Competitive Research of the Selling Sector in the UK. London: Section of Transact and Market. Carlson, S i9000. (1951) Executive Behaviour. Stockholm: Strombergs. Collinson, D. (2005) ‘Dialectics of leadership. ' Human Relations, 58, 1419 - 42. Dalton, M. (1966) Males who Take care of. New York and London: Wiley. Delbridge, L. and L. Lowe (1997) ‘Manufacturing control: supervisory systems on the " new” shopfloor. ' Sociology, 31, 409 - 26. Edwards, G. and Meters. Collinson (2002) ‘Empowerment and managerial time strategies: pragmatism regained. ' Work and Occupations, twenty nine, 272-99. Etzioni, A. (1961) A Relative Analysis of Complex Organisations. New York: Free of charge Press. Felstead, A., A. Fuller, And. Jewson and L. Unwin (2009) Bettering Working while Learning. London: Routledge. Freathy, P. and L. Sets off. (2000) ‘The organisation of working time in large UK food price tag firms. ' In Baret, C., T. Lehndorff and L. Leads to (editors) Adaptable Working Amount of time in Food Selling: a Comparison Between France, Philippines the UK and Japan. Birmingham and New York: Routledge. Gadrey, J. (2000) ‘Working period configurations: theory, methods and assumptions pertaining to an international comparability. ' In Baret, C., S. Lehndorff and L. Sparks (editors) Flexible Operating Time in Meals Retailing: an evaluation Between Portugal, Germany the united kingdom and Asia. London and New York: Routledge. Gamble, L. (2006) ‘Multinational retailers in China: proliferating " McJobs” or developing skills? ' Journal of Management Research, 43, 1463 - 85. Hales, C. (2002) ‘" Bureaucracy-lite” and continuities in managerial function. ' United kingdom Journal of Management, 13, 51-66. Hales, C. (2005) ‘Rooted in supervision, branching into administration: continuity and alter in the role of first-line manager. ' Journal of Management Studies, 42, 471-506. Hart, C., G. Stachow, B. Grazyna, A. Farrell and G. Reed (2006) ‘Employer perceptions of skills gaps in retail: concerns and implications for UK retailers. ' International Record of Price tag and Circulation Management, 35, 271 - 88. Knutson, B. and K. Parry (2008) A Very Short, Reasonably Interesting and Reasonably Cheap Book about Studying Leadership London: Sage. Kelly, S. (2008) ‘Leadership: a categorical mistake? ' Human being Relations, 61, 763 - 82. Kirsch, J., Meters. Klein, H. Lehndorff and D. Voss-Dahm (2000) ‘The organisation of working time in large A language like german food full firms'. In Baret, C., S. Lehndorff, L. Leads to (editors) Versatile Working Time in Food Retailing: a Comparison Between France, Australia the UK and Japan. London and New york city: Routledge. Korczynski, M. (2001) ‘The contradictions of support work: phone centre since customeroriented paperwork. ' In Sturdy, A., I. Grugulis and H. Willmott, (editors) Customer Service: Empowerment and Entrapment. Basingstoke: Palgrave. 18
Korczynski, M. (2002) Human Resource Management in Service Work. Basingstoke: Palgrave. Mason, G., T. Mayhew and M. Osborne (2008) ‘Low paid operate the United Kingdom: a summary. ' In Lloyd, C., G. Builder and E. Mayhew (editors) LowWage Operate the United Kingdom. New york city: Russell Sage Foundation. Mason, G. and M. Osborne (2008) ‘Business strategies, job organisation and low pay in United Kingdom retailing. ' In Lloyd, C., G. Mason and K. Mayhew (editors) Low-Wage Work in the United Kingdom. New York: Russell Sage Basis. McGauran, A-M. (2001) ‘Masculine, feminine or neutral? In-company equal opportunities policies in Irish and French MNC retailing. ' International Record of Hrm, 12, 754-71. McGauran, A-M. (2000) ‘Vive la différence: the gendering of occupational structures within a case study of Irish and French selling. ' Could Studies Worldwide Forum, twenty-three, 613-27. Meindl, J., S i9000. Ehrlich and J. Dukerich (1985) ‘The romance of leadership. ' Administrative Scientific research Quarterly, 30, 78 -- 102. Moss-Kanter, R. (1977) Men and Women from the Corporation. New York: Basic Literature. Nickson, D., C. Warhurst, A. Witz and A-M. Cullen (2001) ‘The significance of being visual: work, employment and services organisation. ' In Strong, A., We. Grugulis and H. Willmott (editors) Customer Service: Empowerment and Entrapment. Basingstoke: Palgrave. Electricity, M. (1997) The Taxation Society. Oxford: Oxford University or college Press. Protherough, R. and J. Choose (2002) Taking care of Britannia. Exeter: Imprint Academic. Pye, Deb. (1968) The type and Fine art of Workmanship. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Rainbird, They would. and A. Munro (2003) ‘Workplace learning and the career relationship inside the public sector. ' Hrm Journal, 13, 30-44. Brown, S. E. and R. Kerr (2009) ‘The representational violence of leadership: a major hermeneutic analyze of leadership and sequence in a United kingdom organisation in the post-Soviet circumstance. ' Individual Relations, 62, 875 -- 903. Rosenthal, P., S. Hill and R. Peccei (1997) ‘Checking out service: evaluating brilliance, HRM and TQM in retailing. ' Work, Work and Culture, 11, 481-503. Smith, V. (1990) Controlling in the Corporate and business Interest: Control and Resistance in an American Bank. Berkley, Los Angeles and Oxford: College or university of Cal Press. Storey, J. (2004a) ‘Changing theories of leadership and command development. ' In Storey, J. (editor) Leadership in Organizations: Current Issues and Future Tendencies. London: Routledge.
Storey, J. (2004b) ‘Signs of change: " damned rascals” and beyond. ' In Storey, T. (editor) Command in Agencies: Current Concerns and Crucial Trends. London: Routledge. The singer, P. and P. Baignade (1999) ‘An assembly line inside the head: function and staff relations in the call centre. ' Industrial Relations Journal, 30, 101-17. Tengblad, H. (2004) ‘Expectations of alignment: examining the link between economic markets and managerial work. ' Corporation Studies 25, 583-606. Watson, T. (1994) In Search of Managing. London: Routledge. Zaleznik, A. (1992) ‘Managers and frontrunners: are they different? ' Harvard Business Assessment 126 - 35.